Wood Siding Vs. Vinyl Siding? 

If you’re deciding between wood siding and vinyl siding, you’re not alone. It’s one of the most common comparisons homeowners make when planning a new build or exterior renovation. And while vinyl has carved out a name for itself in the budget-conscious market, wood remains the gold standard for beauty, authenticity, and long-term value—especially with today’s advancements in protective coatings.

In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of wood siding vs vinyl siding, and introduce you to Timberthane, a durable wood siding solution that gives you the natural look you love—without the usual maintenance headaches.

Cost?

Let’s start with one of the most important questions: How much does it cost?

  • Vinyl Siding is generally cheaper upfront. It’s a plastic product that’s mass-produced, lightweight, and relatively easy to install.

  • Wood Siding can have a higher initial cost, depending on the species and finish. However, with innovations like factory-finished wood siding, that cost includes beauty, longevity, and increased home value.

Pro Tip: When comparing price, consider lifetime value. Wood often outlasts vinyl with proper care and ages more gracefully.

Maintenance?

  • Vinyl Siding is marketed as “low maintenance,” but it can warp, crack, and fade over time—especially in harsh Canadian winters or direct sun. It’s also prone to looking dated as it weathers.

  • Wood Siding traditionally required regular staining or painting, but with products like Timberthane, you get the natural look of wood with a long-lasting protective coating baked right in—meaning far less upkeep than raw wood.

 

Note: Timberthane siding is warrantied for decades of performance and colour retention, with no need for frequent refinishing.

Durability?

  • Vinyl Siding can become brittle over time, particularly in cold climates. Impact from hail, sports equipment, or falling branches can crack it.

  • Wood Siding is incredibly strong—especially if you choose a stable species like pine or cedar, and protect it properly.

That’s where Timberthane shines. It uses a premium grade of wood and a high-performance coating that’s engineered to withstand Ontario’s weather, resist moisture, and prevent peeling or blistering.

 

Aesthetics?

Here’s where wood pulls ahead—by a long shot.

  • Vinyl Siding comes in many colours and patterns, but it often lacks depth and texture. You can spot it from a mile away.

  • Wood Siding offers authentic grain, warmth, and character that synthetic materials simply can’t replicate.

And with Timberthane, you get all the beauty of wood, plus:

  • Dozens of standard colours (or custom ones)

  • A rich matte finish that mimics a freshly painted look

  • Options in board and batten, shiplap, and more

If curb appeal matters to you (and it should), wood wins this round—hands down.

Environmental Impact? 

  • Vinyl is petroleum-based and not biodegradable. It’s difficult to recycle and contributes to landfill waste at end-of-life.

  • Wood is a renewable, biodegradable resource, especially when sourced from responsibly managed forests. Plus, it stores carbon, making it a greener choice overall.

Timberthane siding starts with high-quality, sustainably harvested wood, and is finished in a state-of-the-art facility that prioritizes efficiency and environmental responsibility.

Final Verdict: Which is Better?

  • If you’re prioritizing budget above all, vinyl might be a quick fix. But if you’re investing in your home’s long-term beauty, value, and resilience, wood siding—especially a low-maintenance option like Timberthane—is the clear winner.

Looking for Wood Siding in Ontario?

We’ve got you covered. Whether you’re a homeowner, builder, or designer, we offer premium siding options that are both beautiful and built to last.

Explore our Timberthane siding options — the perfect blend of low-maintenance protection and authentic wood beauty. If you're searching for wood siding Ontario, Timberthane delivers on every front.